Manchester United thrashed in the derby: why Amorim won't change tactics.

According to The Sun: The first Manchester derby of the season once again became a problem for 'United'.

Pep Guardiola's team easily entered the game, confidently winning 3-0 at the 'Etihad' stadium, and the difference in class was obvious.

Ruben Amorim's team was completely outclassed in a match that highlighted the deep issues that 'Old Trafford' still faces.

This defeat reopened wounds that had not healed after a difficult last season, when 'United' found itself at the bottom of the table and suffered a painful defeat in the Europa League final against 'Tottenham'.

Short-lived optimism, sparked by a goalless draw with 'Arsenal' in the opening weekend, has now faded, leaving fans anxious.

After the defeat, Amorim stated that he does not plan to change his rigid 3-4-3 tactics.

However, such tactical rigidity is raising increasing concern. Many experts and fans have begun to doubt 'United's ability to compete at the highest level without the ability to adapt to a stronger opponent.

As shown in the game against 'Man City', faith in a single plan is no substitute for quality and tactical wisdom.

Currently, Amorim has the lowest win percentage among all 'Manchester United' coaches since World War II.

So far, the club's management supports him, but for how long?

Problems of 'United' Under Pressure

Ruben Amorim employs quite a rigid tactic, but there is considerable flexibility in his game plan, especially during high pressing.

When the opponents attack, 'United' are forced to switch between tight, player-oriented pressing and deeper blocking, making it difficult to pass the ball. This tactical uncertainty during the match against 'Man City' led to confusion, allowing 'Man City' to continue their attacks without difficulty.

The main reason for this problem is the central vulnerability of the 3-4-3 system—it relies solely on two central midfielders.

The success of this scheme requires powerful, athletic players capable of covering large distances.

Amorim's choices, Manuel Ugarte, and Bruno Fernandes have proven less than optimal, as none of them possess the elite physical traits required for such a demanding role.

This highlights why the club sought to sign Carlos Baleba from 'Brighton' during the summer transfer window.

It's easy to see why 'Man City' passed through 'United' effortlessly.

This situation indicates the need for a reflection on football at all levels within the club to achieve success in the future.

Conclusion

Amorim's statement after the match that he would not change his system serves as a challenge to the club management. The real problem is that his 3-4-3 scheme has become too frequently exposed and countered by coaches in the Premier League to serve as a foundation for consistent success.

If 'United' are serious about returning to the top, Amorim's refusal to adapt his tactics will likely be the reason for his departure from the club.